Abstract

Objectives

The Incredible Years Teacher® Classroom Management (IY-TCM) intervention is associated with short-term improvements in mental health difficulties in young people. The aim was to estimate the long-term impact and cost-effectiveness of the IY-TCM intervention compared with no intervention.

Methods

An existing health economic model (LifeSim 1.0) was used to translate short-term changes in the Strength and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ), based on the Supporting Teachers and childRen in Schools cluster randomized controlled trial of the IY-TCM intervention in schools, into estimated medium- and long-term effects using multiple longitudinal data sets. LifeSim 1.0 was adapted to incorporate teacher-reported SDQ and account for individual heterogeneity. Cost-effectiveness analyses were conducted using the trial-based intervention cost with subgroup analyses on deprivation, conduct scores and parental depression in the simulated baseline population.

Results

Regression analyses show significant predictor variables for intervention effectiveness, including deprivation and baseline SDQ. LifeSim results indicate small gains in long-term outcomes, and cost-effective analyses estimated that the IY-TCM intervention could be cost-effective, but there was a large amount of uncertainty (net monetary benefit = £10, Estimated CI = −£134, £156). Benefits and certainty of cost-effectiveness were greater for some subgroups, such as those with high conduct scores at baseline (net monetary benefit = £206, Estimated CI = £26, £318).

Conclusions

IY-TCM could be cost-effective, but there was a large amount of uncertainty around costs and benefits. Greater benefits for pupils with difficulties at baseline suggest that the intervention may be more cost-effective for schools in more deprived areas with high levels of conduct problems.